• Sarah Little

Property that Re-Vests on Confirmation is Not Property of the Estate in Chapter 13


In In re Black, the 9th Circuit BAP overturned the bankruptcy court and held that a Chapter 13 Trustee cannot modify a chapter 13 plan to require debtors to turnover proceeds from the sale of their real property that re-vested with the debtors when their plan was confirmed if not provided for by the confirmed plan.

The Debtor's schedules valued the property at $44,000 and provided for a $45,000 payment from proceeds of the sale of the the property to occur in the 4th year of the plan. The property sold for $107,000 and the Chapter 13 Trustee tried to require, through a plan modification, the debtor to turnover all the proceeds, because the property was not exempt. The Trustee argued post-petition appreciation was property of the estate pursuant to Section 1306(a)(1) or section 541(a)(6). The court held that section 1327(b) is controlling, which provides that confirmation of the plan re-vests property in the debtor free and clear of any claim or interest of any creditor provide for the plan. Post-petition appreciation therefore did not accrue from estate property and belonged to the Debtors. See opinion here.


Recent Posts

See All

The Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019

On August 23, 2019 the Small Business Reorganization Act (“SBRA”) was signed into law. The SBRA becomes effective on February 19, 2020. The SBRA is found in Subchapter V of Chapter 11 of the Bankruptc

© 2020 by Kornfield, Nyberg, Bendes, Kuhner & Little P.C.